Restaurant hero image
Authentic New York Style Pizza

5-Star pizzeria with New York-style pies, stromboli, subs & salads. Our recipe has withstood the test of time for over 90 years.

Section main imageSection feature image
Section main imageSection feature image
Welcome to Buckeye Pizza

We have been serving the Westerville and Easton area for over 12 years. We pride ourselves on making sure the pizza dough and sauce are made fresh daily.

Takeout • Delivery
Takeout, Delivery
What people are saying...
“The food is ALWAYS fresh and hot when we get it delivered, and the delivery guy, well he cant be beat! LOVE THIS PLACE!!!”
Steve S.
“Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli is the shiznit!!!! I travel all around the state of Ohio and this is by far the best pizza in Ohio!! That sauce tho.... Lip smacking delicious!!”
Jack
“The food here just hits different compared to a franchise. You can taste the love and home made goodness they put into their pizzas and food here. Absolutely excellent quality. The meatball pizza and fried ravioli is great. Strombolis are even better, the recipe is over 100 years old. You can't get a stromboli like that from these franchise places. Would recommend for sure!”
Mandy D.
“Customer service is wonderful there! They have the best pizza & Stromboli I've had in all of Columbus & I've lived here my whole life. It really puts all the high industry pizza places to shame. Its always fresh and hot. Its a super friendly place to be.”
Morgan D.
“Great quality food you can taste the fresh ingredients in every bite. I love the huge selection of food they have pizza, stromboli, pasta, salads, and a ton of appetizers to choose from. The staff is always friendly and accommodates any requests i have. They have a great genuine pizza shop vibe. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for good food.”
Lizz D.
1 / 2